A new report authored in March 2019 finds that tax disputes at Tax Appeals Tribunal (TAT) take a long time to be finalized. “On average, only 6 cases worth Shs2.3 billion were finalized within 12 months of lodgment during the period of the study, representing yearly average completion rates as low as 16.6 percent,” says the report by7 the Economic Policy Research Centre (EPRC).
“The timeliness of tax dispute resolution by the TAT was taken into account by considering the number of tax dispute cases finalized within 12 months of lodgment,” report, dubbed ‘Court Actions and Boosting Domestic Revenue Mobilization in Uganda’says.
A total of 37 finalized tax cases spanning the period 2000 to 2017 were reviewed in order to identify the major facts of disputation involved in tax disputes at says EPRC in its report. The tax disputes were between the Uganda Revenue Authority (URA) and individual taxpayers and companies.
While the number of tax disputes finalized within 12 months of lodgment doubled between 2015 and 2016, overall, the number of cases finalized beyond 12 months of lodgment was greater for all years studied. “The high number of cases finalized beyond 12 months of lodgment partly explains the large amount of tax revenue trapped in tax disputes,” the report says.
Outcomes of tax dispute cases
According to Brian Sserunjogi and Paul Corti Lakuma, EPRC researchers, who authored the report, the results on the outcome of tax disputes indicate that during the study period, the tax commissioner’s assessment and… decisions were upheld in about 24 percent of the tax disputes and varied in only 13 percent of the cases.
In addition, about 25 percent of the tax disputes lodged at TAT were withdrawn by applicants while 13 percent of the tax disputes were dismissed by the tribunal. It is also worth noting that about 25 percent of the cases at TAT were finalized by mutual consent between URA and companies.
According to the report, the large percentage of cases finalized through mutual consent and withdrawn is an indication of the aggressive assessments and tax audits undertaken by URA in order to meet annual revenue targets. This is because after a review with TAT, most taxpayers reach an agreement with the URA.
“Taxpayers withdraw their applications in the interest of saving time, since the court process takes a long time. As already mentioned, the TAT does not have targets with regards to the number of cases to be finalized within a particular time. Unlike in Rwanda, where the law stipulates a maximum period of six months from filing to judgement for all courts, tax disputes in Uganda can last for significantly longer periods,” the report says.
It says the lack of performance targets derails the speed of resolution of the cases at TAT. Furthermore, a breakdown of the outcome of the tax disputes between URA and taxpayers reveals that during the study period, on average both sides won an equal number of cases. The findings reveal that there is no overt bias in the TAT ruling.
Nonetheless, the report says, the value of taxes involved for cases decided in URA’s favour were on average greater than that decided in the favour of taxpayers. “This is an indication that URA audits and reassessments tend to be skewed toward large taxpayers. The evidence further reveals that overall, both the number of cases decided in favour of the URA and taxpayers exhibited a declining trend during the study period,” it says.
The observed trend in the outcome of the tax disputes could be partly be attributed to an increasing number of cases that are either dismissed, consented or withdrawn before final TAT ruling is reached. Hence is a need to strengthen URA’s audit and assessment functions to reduce on aggressive assessments which sometimes result in frivolous cases which are either dismissed, withdrawn or consented after reassessment by TAT.
Appeals to the High Court
According to the report, with regards to the number of tax disputes for appeal to High Court, findings reveal that during the study period, an average of one case per year proceeded for appeal at the High Court from the TAT. The low number of cases that proceed for appeal to the High court is partly attributed to the heavy backlog of cases at the High Court. According to the National Court Case Census (2016), the High Court, registered the second highest number (32 percent) of pending cases in the Judiciary.
The report says: “The High Court registered a total of 36,313 pending cases of which 10,723 were civil cases. The high contribution of civil cases to the total pending cases at the High Court is an indication that tax disputes take significant amounts of time to be heard and let alone resolved. There is no priority given to tax related disputes at the High Court since all cases are treated the same way.”
The report cites Section 27 of the TAT Act states that appeals to the High Court from TAT are to be made on questions of law only. Therefore; it says, filing of appeals to the High Court implies that tax disputes are heard like conventional cases, requiring strict adherence to the Civil Procedure Act, which follows the law and court procedures strictly. “This slows down the process of tax dispute resolution at the High court,” it says.
Types of tax dispute cases
The report indicates that majority of tax disputes lodged at TAT are filed by the large taxpayers. Specifically, tax disputes filed by corporations averaged 24 cases per year worth Shs19 billion against an average of 2 cases per year worth Shs390 million from individual small tax payers.
The results confirm the barriers that confront small taxpayers in accessing tax justice in Uganda. A number of reasons are provided for the observed trend. First, small taxpayers are unable to pay the mandatory 30 percent of the tax assessed or that part of the tax assessed not in dispute whichever is greater as specified in the TAT Act, the report says.
Secondly, it says, small taxpayers lack the necessary requisite requirements such books of accounts, formal registration, and legal representation of a tax lawyer required for a formal TAT hearing. In addition, small taxpayers fear to approach the court because they fear that URA may harass them. Moreover, it says, URA tax audits have previously targeted large tax payers, with little or no concern on the small taxpayers. Also, the tax amounts involved with small taxpayers are usually small and do not attract small taxpayers to go through all the bureaucracy of the TAT process.
prednisone 1 mg tablet: http://prednisone1st.store/# prednisone 50 mg canada
asian dating chat: dating sims free online japanese adult – best dating site
cost cheap mobic price: how can i get generic mobic pills – can you get mobic for sale
https://pharmacyreview.best/# canadian pharmacy online
https://pharmacyreview.best/# canadian pharmacy 365
best online canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy 24 com
buy cheap propecia pills generic propecia without insurance
where to buy cheap mobic without a prescription [url=https://mobic.store/#]where to get cheap mobic[/url] can i purchase cheap mobic no prescription
amoxicillin 500mg buy online canada: [url=http://amoxicillins.com/#]amoxicillin discount[/url] amoxicillin 500 mg for sale
http://cheapestedpills.com/# the best ed pills
can i purchase mobic price: mobic pills – buy generic mobic pill
canadapharmacyonline pharmacies in canada that ship to the us
https://pharmacyreview.best/# canadian pharmacy victoza
[url=https://propecia1st.science/#]buy cheap propecia for sale[/url] order generic propecia price
purchase amoxicillin online without prescription amoxicillin tablets in india – amoxicillin 500mg price
Generic Name.
where buy cheap mobic without dr prescription: where to get cheap mobic without rx – cost of cheap mobic prices
Some trends of drugs.
cost of generic propecia price generic propecia for sale
erectile dysfunction medicines: new ed treatments – the best ed pills
https://propecia1st.science/# cost cheap propecia without prescription
[url=https://pharmacyreview.best/#]medication canadian pharmacy[/url] legitimate canadian pharmacies
rx propecia cost of propecia for sale
canadian pharmacy online canadian pharmacy mall
[url=https://propecia1st.science/#]order generic propecia without insurance[/url] order propecia pills
https://propecia1st.science/# cheap propecia without dr prescription
trusted canadian pharmacy: canadianpharmacyworld – canadian pharmacy 365
http://certifiedcanadapharm.store/# cheapest pharmacy canada
buy zithromax online no prescription
order zithromax online without prescription
metformin ingredients
metformin type 1 diabetes
flagyl for stomach pain
zoloft adverse effects
furosemide 12.5 mg for dogs dosage
can furosemide cause a false positive drug test
what time of day should i take zoloft
lisinopril valsartan
does flagyl turn your urine dark
lisinopril 5 mg
lasix for water retention
glimepiride glucophage
gabapentin for anxiety dose
gabapentin side effects dogs
escitalopram manufacturer
amoxicillin dose
cephalexin 500 mg para que sirve efectos secundarios
does gabapentin make you high
trazodone and gabapentin for dogs dosage
para que sirve cephalexin 500
escitalopram indication
how to use ciprofloxacin ear drops
bactrim prophylaxis
cephalexin dosage for adults
amoxicillin and weed
bactrim pediatric dosing chart
does bactrim treat bv
can bactrim make you tired
amoxicillin mechanism of action
cephalexin dog
snorting escitalopram
what is escitalopram
ddavp comprimidos
cozaar 50 mg generico
citalopram nausea
citalopram half life
cozaar drug interactions
depakote withdrawal
ddavp nasal dose
depakote 500 mg twice a day
ddavp ipss
cozaar 5 mg
citalopram used for
citalopram vs lexapro
cozaar 100 mg tablet
depakote er vs dr
depakote er side effects
how ddavp works
diltiazem 60 mg tab
augmentin 875mg
drug bank of ezetimibe
rash from augmentin
ezetimibe and pravastatin
diclofenac side effects long term use
diclofenac and tramadol
diltiazem calcium channel blocker
contrave 50mg
flomax hernia
can effexor cause insomnia
flomax 0.4 mg drug
does effexor cause hair loss
cyclobenzaprine vs flexeril
does flexeril make you sleepy
what is the percent by mass of hydrogen in aspirin c9h8o4
can you overdose on amitriptyline
allopurinol cost cvs
allopurinol reviews
how long does it take for amitriptyline to work
aripiprazole medication
how much aspirin for a dog
aripiprazole interactions
augmentin 875 125 mg
bupropion cost
celebrex adverse reactions
common side effects of celebrex
bupropion hydrobromide
baclofen or flexeril
augmentin for uti
wellbutrin with celexa
buspirone and hot flashes
how to pronounce celecoxib
celecoxib 200 mg
buspar pill
ashwagandha dose
celexa coupon
examine ashwagandha
acarbose degradation
abilify half life
mГ©dicament actos
abilify for depression
acarbose prontuario
raw semaglutide
protonix dosage
estimation of repaglinide
remeron for sleep
remeron review
repaglinide mims
robaxin vs zanaflex
side effects protonix
what is robaxin compared to
protonix 40 mg tablet
repaglinide floating
ivermectin 8 mg
sitagliptin metformin 50 850 price
wellbutrin synthroid
provera synthroid
sitagliptin severe side effects
spironolactone overdose
how long for spironolactone to work for acne
synthroid anorexia
tizanidine 40 mg
kombination tamsulosin finasterid
voltaren gel for back spasms
venlafaxine cost without insurance cvs
how long does tizanidine stay in your urine
venlafaxine and vyvanse
zofran 4 mg nebenwirkungen
zetia dosing
buying prescription drugs in mexico online: mexican online pharmacies prescription drugs – mexican drugstore online
zyprexa constipation
zyprexa hair loss
ezetimibe zetia
wellbutrin 300 xr
п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india http://indiaph24.store/# cheapest online pharmacy india
Online medicine home delivery
can zofran help with the stomach flu
flagyl and zofran
can you cut zyprexa in half
celexa and zyprexa
wellbutrin cytomel interaction
zofran is it safe
tadalafil expiration date
buy levitra 20 mg online
cialis quick ship
cialis mexico
levitra online
cheap levitra
tadalafil and alcohol
buy brand levitra online
cialis dapoxetine overnight shipping canada
levitra or cialis
tadalafil 10mg
tadalafil citrate dosage
levitra purchase cheap
levitra price