Aine Kaguta wins bid to stop Lawyer Tumwebaze from conducting own election petition

Must read

Simon Kabayohttps://eagle.co.ug
Reporter whose work is detailed

The High Court in Masaka has ruled that lawyer Tumwebaze Jet John Ndamagi cannot represent himself as an advocate in an election petition challenging the election of Mawogola North MP Aine Godfrey Kaguta, holding that an advocate who is a principal witness in contentious proceedings cannot simultaneously conduct the same case as legal counsel.

In a ruling delivered on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, Justice Bernard Namanya granted an application by Kaguta seeking to stop Tumwebaze from appearing as an advocate in Election Petition No. 10 of 2026, in which the lawyer is challenging the results of the January 15, 2026 parliamentary election in Mawogola North Constituency.

The judge held that Tumwebaze had placed himself in a position where he was both a litigant and a principal witness whose evidence was central to the dispute, making it professionally improper for him to continue conducting the proceedings from the bar as an advocate.

The application, registered as Miscellaneous Application No. 17 of 2026, arose from Tumwebaze’s decision to conduct his own election petition despite having sworn affidavits containing evidence on the contested issues.

Kaguta, through his lawyers, challenged the arrangement, arguing that Tumwebaze’s dual role violated Regulation 9 of the Advocates (Professional Conduct) Regulations, which prohibits an advocate who is required to give evidence on a contentious matter from appearing as counsel in the same proceedings.

The court heard that Tumwebaze, a practising advocate with Kampala Associated Advocates, had sworn the principal affidavit in support of his election petition and another affidavit in rejoinder.

These affidavits contained evidence relating to the allegations raised in the petition and were central to the issues the court would be required to determine.

Kaguta’s lawyers argued that Tumwebaze could not be allowed to present evidence as a witness and subsequently participate in the same proceedings as the advocate responsible for examining witnesses, making legal submissions and conducting the petition.

They maintained that the restriction was intended to preserve the integrity of court proceedings and prevent the complications that arise when an advocate becomes personally involved in disputed facts that he is also expected to prove.

Tumwebaze opposed the application, insisting that he had a right to represent himself because he was appearing in his personal capacity as the petitioner and was not representing another person.

He argued that his status as a practising advocate did not take away his right to conduct his own case and that the professional restriction should not be interpreted to prevent an individual lawyer from appearing in court on his own behalf.

He further maintained that Kaguta had not demonstrated any actual prejudice arising from his decision to represent himself.

However, Justice Namanya rejected that interpretation, explaining that Regulation 9 addresses the conflict created by an advocate simultaneously occupying the positions of counsel and witness, rather than merely regulating the relationship between an advocate and a client.

“The prohibition is directed at the dual role itself: an Advocate who is, or has reason to believe that he will be, required to give evidence on a contentious matter may not appear as an Advocate in that matter, whether he acts for a client or for himself,” Justice Namanya ruled.

The judge observed that the election petition was unquestionably contentious and that Tumwebaze’s affidavits were not peripheral documents but contained evidence going to the heart of the dispute.

“The Respondent is the Petitioner in Election Petition No. 10 of 2026, which is a contentious matter, and has sworn both the principal affidavit in support of the Petition and an affidavit in rejoinder, which go to the heart of the contested allegations and on which he will be liable to cross-examination,” Namanya observed.

The judge explained that once Tumwebaze placed himself at the centre of the disputed facts through his sworn evidence, he became a principal witness in the proceedings and could not continue exercising the professional responsibilities of an advocate in the same case.

“He is a principal witness in the Election Petition and cannot, at the same time, conduct the Petition from the bar as an Advocate and an officer of this Court,” the judge ruled.

Justice Namanya further explained that the restriction was not dependent on whether an advocate was representing another person or conducting personal litigation. What mattered was whether the advocate was required to give evidence on a contentious issue in the same proceedings.

The court relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in Uganda Development Bank v M/S Kasirye, Byaruhanga and Company Advocates, a case that addressed the professional restrictions applicable to advocates who are also required to testify in contentious proceedings.

The Supreme Court’s position was that an advocate cannot simultaneously perform the duties of legal counsel and become a witness on disputed matters in the same case.

Justice Namanya adopted that reasoning, emphasising that an advocate faced with such circumstances must choose between the two professional roles.

“In the words of the Supreme Court in the Uganda Development Bank case (supra), he must forfeit one of the two hats,” the judge ruled.

The court consequently granted Kaguta’s application and issued an order prohibiting Tumwebaze from appearing as an advocate in the substantive election petition.

The decision means that although Tumwebaze remains entitled to pursue his election challenge as the petitioner, he cannot continue conducting the proceedings in his professional capacity as a lawyer while remaining a principal witness in the same case.

The ruling does not, however, dismiss the election petition or determine the merits of the allegations against Kaguta. It deals specifically with the question of whether Tumwebaze can simultaneously act as counsel and witness.

The main election petition pits Tumwebaze against Kaguta, the Electoral Commission and Aryaija Gracious following the January 15, 2026 parliamentary elections in which Kaguta was declared the winner of the Mawogola North seat.

Tumwebaze, who contested against Kaguta, subsequently went to court seeking to challenge the election outcome.

The dispute has generated several legal battles, including an earlier application in which Tumwebaze sought to stop lawyer Paul Kuteesa and Arcadia Advocates from representing Kaguta, alleging that Kuteesa had previously represented him and obtained confidential information relating to his intended election petition.

However, in a separate ruling delivered on September 22, 2026, Justice Thomas Ocaya dismissed that application after finding that Tumwebaze had failed to establish sufficient evidence of an advocate-client relationship or the alleged disclosure of confidential information.

The decision therefore concerns a different legal question: whether Tumwebaze, having sworn affidavits on the contested issues in his own election petition, can continue appearing as the advocate conducting the proceedings.

Justice Namanya’s ruling reinforces the professional standards governing advocates in Uganda and the importance of separating the responsibilities of a legal representative from those of a witness in contentious court proceedings.

The judge directed that the costs of the application would abide by the outcome of the main election petition.

More articles

- Advertisement -

Latest article

- Advertisement -